Gary Lineker isn’t holding back when it comes to Manchester United’s transfer decisions. On his popular podcast, the former England legend called out United for letting Scott McTominay go in the first place, and says they should make every effort to bring him back. The reason? McTominay’s bulldog mentality and impressive record at Napoli stand in sharp contrast with United’s flat midfield performances this season.
Since his £25 million switch to Serie A last summer, McTominay has been more than a squad player for Napoli. He’s racked up nine goals and two assists, driving them right into the thick of the title race. That’s not just solid for a midfielder, it’s the kind of output Manchester United could only dream of from their own engine room lately.
Lineker watched McTominay’s latest performances closely—especially that thunderbolt of a goal last weekend—and argued that his aggression and energy are exactly what new United manager Ruben Amorim needs to patch up his leaking midfield. Amorim, known for a system that rewards hard runners and high-pressers, could use someone who thrives off a battle and still contributes on the scoreboard.
But for Lineker, the biggest frustration isn’t just seeing McTominay thriving abroad. It’s about why United let him leave. He tore into the Profit and Sustainability Rules—the Premier League’s attempt to keep clubs financially responsible—which he slammed as ‘nonsensical’ and ‘ridiculous.’ According to Lineker, selling talents like McTominay to balance the books hurts not only United’s results but the entire competitive pulse of the league.
Fans are seeing a pattern here. From McTominay shining in Italy, to other United alumni finding their spark after moving on—Lineker also points to Marcus Rashford’s improved form elsewhere—there’s a sense Old Trafford has become a place where good players go stale. For a club knee-deep in their worst domestic campaign in decades, missing out on homegrown drive and physicality only adds insult to injury.
So, while Amorim faces mounting pressure to fix things fast, Lineker’s advice is simple: focus less on the accountants, and more on bringing back players who fit the system and breathe life into the badge. For United, re-signing a reborn McTominay might just be the first step toward healing their battered midfield and restoring some lost pride on the pitch.
Write a comment